![]() When the alleged corruption is inextricably intertwined with governmental operation, the exposure and prosecution of such an abuse of public trust are necessarily political. “concluding that Grava’s whistleblowing could not constitute an expression of political opinion because he did not concomitantly espouse political theory. Thus, official retaliation against those who expose and prosecute governmental corruption may, in appropriate circumstances, amount to persecution on account of political opinion.” Refusal to accede to government corruption can constitute a political opinion for purposes of refugee status. INS, 105 F.3d 374, 381 (7th Cir.1997) (writing that political agitation against state corruption might well be a ground for asylum). However, where the whistle blows against corrupt government officials, it may constitute political activity sufficient to form the basis of persecution on account of political opinion. “Whistleblowing against one’s supervisors at work is not, as a matter of law, always an exercise of political opinion. Immigration and Naturalization Service that “a whistleblower who exposes government corruption… may claim asylum on account of persecution arising from these activities.” The Court noted that Grava’s “tormentors” were not “mere criminals or guerrilla forces,” but rather they were “instruments of the government itself.” Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided in Dionesio Calunsag Grava v. ![]() As a result, he endured severe retaliation and he received death threats, and so fled to the U.S. He attempted to blow the whistle on this entrenched corruption, which included ties to the Philippine Congress. The landmark case concerned Dionesio Grava, who worked for the Philippine Government when he witnessed corrupt supervisors profiting from smuggling schemes. Essentially, courts have recognized whistleblowers as a protected class, and therefore deserving of political asylum, in some circumstances. have decided that whistleblowers who face persecution in their home countries might be entitled to political asylum in the U.S. Understanding the Court Decisions Protecting Whistleblowers Through Political AsylumĬourts in the U.S.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |